Document Type : Original Article
Authors
1
1. Department of Architecture, Ardabil Branch, Islamic Azad Univercity, Ardabil, Iran.
2
Department of Architecture, Ardabil Branch, Islamic Azad Univercity, Ardabil, Iran.
10.48311/udd.2026.120777.82834
Abstract
**Aim:** Intermediate cities face challenges in maintaining place identity amid rapid development and architectural interventions that may overlook local historical, cultural, and social contexts. This study develops a framework for evaluating such interventions, drawing on Hegelian *Aufhebung* and the physical, semantic, and social dimensions of place.
**Methodology:** This developmental-applied study uses an analytical-inferential approach. *Aufhebung* is conceptualised through negation, preservation, and elevation. The built environment is then differentiated into three layers: physical–structural, semantic–semiotic, and social–interactive. Operational indicators are derived by integrating these foundations. For each indicator, the study identifies its dominant dialectical orientation, theoretical basis, and proposed assessment method. It also develops a five-point scoring protocol, observable assessment criteria, and a procedure for diagnosing tensions among indicators.
**Findings:** The framework comprises 26 indicators: nine physical–structural, eight semantic–semiotic, and nine social–interactive. Observable criteria clarify how evidence informs their assessment. A diagnostic matrix identifies potential tensions between indicators and across layers. Results are interpreted through three independent layer profiles rather than a single aggregate score. Indicators scoring 1 or 2 are independently flagged for further examination and corrective action, regardless of other indicators’ performance.
**Conclusion:** By linking *Aufhebung* to the physical, semantic, and social dimensions of place, the framework structures the evaluation of architectural interventions in intermediate cities. It reveals layer-specific weaknesses, supports tension analysis, and informs intervention priorities. It does not automatically resolve tensions or replace informed, context-sensitive expert judgement. As a theoretical–methodological proposal, however, its reliability, practical applicability, and context sensitivity require empirical testing and localisation across different intermediate-city settings.
Keywords
Subjects